Sunday, 19 March 2023

What is art for?

Sunday, 19th

To the ROM for an exhibition of paintings, some of them prompted by ROM exhibits, by a Canadian painter Kent Monkman and his studio.

The underlying thesis is a new, indigenous world view through the character of a mischievous ancient character, Chief Miss Testickle; a cross dressing water spirit.


The first section of the exhibition is devoted to this myth and to perfectly reasonable claims of precedent in the land.  We were Guided and explained by three, 20-something Indigenous women. "This last picture is of life before the great disruption".....




And I get that.

I get the desolation of the sparrow, the abomination of the Residential Schools  and I get the grave injustice and terrible harm caused by them. I really do.



But what am I supposed to do?

"No apology, no weeping can remedy the past and yet you give me no vision even of what future YOU want, let alone the future we can think of building together. All you tell me is that your history is older than mine, probably more valid than mine and that it is certainly a history that you seem to long to revive and return to.

“Brutality, oppression, occupation and displacement have been a universal story all over the world. I hate it and I try to find some response to it; some way of redressing the horror.

"I can take you to innumerable sites in France where middle-of-nowhere memorials record the atrocities of the Nazi invaders to the local population. I can show you the beach in Britain where Normans, a cut above the others in their exquisite brutality, came to destroy a stable Saxon society. I can take you to sites where Viking invaders, every bit as brutal as the Nazis, cut down and dismembered peaceful monks and nuns and stole priceless treasures. I can take you to Brick Lane where British Blackshirts flaunted their Arian “superiority” over the immigrant community taking shelter there. And that is just MY history.  Doesn't anyone remember the holocaust?

The Indigenous population of North America – of the Americas for that matter, have no exclusive claim on repression and abuse.  I don’t want to write this but I am facing a blank wall!


Kent Monkman - as presented by these three young women, shows me no way forward.

 

Except perhaps this image.  Is it enough that our young people hear and understand?  Is it?



But the three young women when I asked them the question, just half smiled and said nothing.

And I feel that the exhibition demands a response.

Hmm.


I thought that the images and the technique were remarkable, the story captivating; the ending as described difficult – at least for me.  Was he well served by his presenters?


Supper together was in Chinatown; a rollicking feast!


No comments:

Post a Comment